That Shane Gillis ESPYs Joke Is Aging Well—WNBA All-Stars Rejected at Nightclub Door

Updated
We publish independently audited content meeting strict editorial standards. Ads on our site are served by Google AdSense and are not controlled or influenced by our editorial team.
That Shane Gillis ESPYs Joke Is Aging Well—WNBA All-Stars Rejected at Nightclub Door

Several WNBA All-Stars were denied entry to a nightclub in Indianapolis after the 2025 All-Star Game. Among them were Courtney Williams and Natisha Hiedeman. Video shows the players waiting outside, explaining they had just played in the league’s showcase event. The club staff didn’t recognize them and initially refused to let them skip the line.

WNBA Players Denied Entry at Indianapolis Nightclub

CLICK VIDEO BELOW TO PLAY

The incident happened hours after the WNBA All-Star Game ended. Williams and Hiedeman tried to enter the club without waiting, telling the bouncers they were WNBA players. That didn’t matter. They were told to wait with everyone else. Eventually, someone from the venue let them in after confirming who they were. But by then, the moment had gone viral.

Why the WNBA All-Star Club Snub Went Viral

The story spread fast online because it underlined a bigger issue: recognition. These weren’t unknown players. For example, Williams has been in the league since 2016. But outside of a few top stars, most WNBA players still aren’t recognized by the general public, even on the night of their own All-Star event.

Shane Gillis Joke About WNBA Resurfaces

Comedian Shane Gillis recent joke at the ESPYs where he introduced his friend’s wife as a WNBA All-Star has already aged well. The club incident gave the bit new life. Fans online pointed out that if this had been NBA players, the door would’ve opened immediately.

The common punchline: “Caitlin Clark would’ve gotten in.”

WNBA Recognition Still Lacking in 2025

This wasn’t a back-alley bar in a random city. It was a club in the All-Star host city, on All-Star night, turning away All-Stars. And still, no one recognized them. The players had to vouch for themselves and still weren’t believed. That’s the visibility gap.

Clark, Angel Reese, and A’ja Wilson have changed that for themselves. The rest of the league hasn’t caught up. It shows in situations like this, when being elite on the court doesn’t get you past a velvet rope.

Fan Reaction to WNBA All-Stars Getting Turned Away

Opinions online were split. Some criticized the club for not knowing who was in town. Others said the players should’ve expected to wait. The moment became a flashpoint for how the WNBA is viewed outside its base. Players want respect. But respect doesn’t come if people don’t know who you are.

The video wasn’t shocking. It was expected. And that’s the issue.