The New York Giants enter the 2026 offseason with one of the most intriguing coaching vacancies in the NFL after firing Brian Daboll during the 2025 season following a disappointing 4-13 record. Interim coach Mike Kafka finished the year, but the front office and owner family clearly want a fresh start.
Giants Coaching Odds: Who Are The Three Favorites To Win The Job?
Below, we take a look at three of the candidates who are most likely to land the job, based on the betting odds put out by the oddsmakers at BetOnline:
Kevin Stefanski (+110)
Kevin Stefanski tops the current odds board as the slight favorite to become the Giants’ next head coach. The former Cleveland Browns head coach was recently fired after a 5-12 campaign in 2025, ending a six-year tenure that included two NFL Coach of the Year awards and multiple playoff runs earlier in his stint.
Stefanski is an offensive architect with a proven track record of developing quarterbacks and structuring balanced, run-first attacks that complement elite wide receivers and running backs. His tenure in Cleveland showcased his ability to win with tough, physical football, and his previous success could be enticing for a Giants roster boasting young talent like quarterback Jaxson Dart.
Stefanski also brings credibility as a former head coach who has built team culture and accountability, a quality New York desperately needs after three consecutive losing seasons and organizational turmoil.
John Harbaugh (+150)
Former Baltimore Ravens head coach John Harbaugh has quickly emerged as a leading candidate for the Giants job after his dismissal from Baltimore, where he spent 18 seasons and became one of the most respected leaders in the league.
Harbaugh’s resume speaks for itself. He is a Super Bowl champion, perennial playoff contender, and coach known for steady leadership, game management, and defensive acumen. Bringing Harbaugh to East Rutherford would provide the Giants with a coach who not only has championship experience, but also a calming presence capable of steadying a franchise that has struggled with consistency.
Mike McCarthy (+800)
At longer odds, Mike McCarthy remains in the mix as a veteran coach with a long NFL résumé. McCarthy’s head coaching career includes a Super Bowl title with the Green Bay Packers and extended stints leading both the Dallas Cowboys and Packers.
While McCarthy has bounced around the league and faced criticism in recent years, his experience managing big personalities and navigating playoff environments could appeal to Giants decision-makers looking for someone who has been there before. As a seasoned coach, McCarthy brings familiarity with NFL pressure and media scrutiny, a factor that could help the Giants rebuild confidence and identity.
