Skip to main content

While many believe Tom Brady put an end to any debate on whether he’s the NFL GOAT by winning his seventh Super Bowl, an interesting metric from our friends over at Pro Football Reference says otherwise.

In 2019, PFR created a “Hall of Fame Monitor” that tracks a current player’s chances of being inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. A point system was created using approximate value, Super Bowl wins, All-Pro and Pro Bowl selections, various statistical milestones, and other factors to essentially create a pecking order at each position. This system could obviously be used to create an overall list as well.

Past NFL players are also included in the metric, which makes things more interesting as it can create a lot of those controversial GOAT arguments people love so much — arguments that Tom Brady has been a part of for years.

So on that note, let’s look at the metric that essentially says TB12 is just the third-greatest player in NFL history and not even the highest-ranked quarterback.

Jerry Rice, not Tom Brady, is considered the NFL GOAT using this metric

While there’s long been a debate on whether Tom Brady is the greatest quarterback of all time, there isn’t much of a debate about the greatest wide receiver in NFL history.

The consensus is that Jerry Rice holds that title, and the PFR metric says it’s not even close. It also indicates that, overall, Rice is the greatest player in NFL history. He has more points than any player in history under the metric with 311.81, more than double that of the next-closest receiver on the list, Randy Moss, who has 149.59 points. Tom Brady currently has 250.94 assigned to him.

While the retired QB might have more Super Bowl wins than Rice (seven to three), the Hall of Fame receiver has six more overall All-Pro selections (11 to five) and seven more First-Team selections (10 to three).

Peyton Manning, not Tom Brady, is ranked as the top quarterback

Regarding the quarterback position, Tom Brady’s longtime rival, Peyton Manning, is listed as the top QB using the PFR metric. He has 258 points to Brady’s 250.94.

Again, while Brady has more Super Bowl wins than Manning (seven to two) as well as the edge in head-to-head meetings (11 to six), Manning holds the advantage in NFL MVP wins (five to three), overall All-Pro selections (10 to five), and First-Team All-Pro selections (seven to three).

Another one of TB12’s competitors in the GOAT conversation, Joe Montana, is only the sixth-ranked quarterback

Outside of Peyton Manning, the other quarterback usually mentioned in the GOAT conversation with Tom Brady is Joe Montana. Surprisingly, he’s only the sixth-ranked QB in the metric with 153.45 points. The four-time Super Bowl champ ranks behind Manning (258.00), Brady (250.94), Brett Favre (178.84), Aaron Rodgers (163.72), and Johnny Unitas (160.34).

Is this an exact science? No. But it’s certainly a fun and interesting way to look at things, and it’s an easy way to get Brady’s fans all riled up.

For those who might be curious, the highest-rated running back is Walter Payton (214.91), and the highest-rated defensive player is Reggie White (237.75).

For all the details on how this metric works, head on over to Pro Football Reference.


Tom Brady’s Greatest Triumphs: Ranking the Top 7 Highlights of His Football Career